Crows Make Visual Decisions Twice as Fast as Humans
Scientists at the University of Tübingen have found that crows make visual decisions about twice as fast as humans and monkeys, while staying highly accurate. In the experiment, two carrion crows needed an average of just 235 milliseconds to spot the direction of a moving dot pattern and pick their answer. The study was published in the journal Science.
Who Did the Study?
The research was carried out by Philipp Schmidbauer and Professor Andreas Nieder of the University of Tübingen’s Institute of Neurobiology.
How Was the Experiment Done?
- The crows watched moving dots on a touchscreen.
- They had to decide whether the dots were mostly moving left or right.
- They showed their choice by pecking at a target on the same side as the motion.

What Did the Crows Achieve?
- They needed only 235 milliseconds on average to decide.
- With clear signals, they reached nearly 100% accuracy.
- Even when the motion was hard to recognise, their choices were still better than random guessing, said Schmidbauer.
What Happened Inside the Crow Brain?
The researchers measured the activity of neurons in the nidopallium caudolaterale, a key part of the crow brain that is similar to the human prefrontal cortex.
- Just 70 milliseconds after the visual cue began, the neurons started to show different signals for each motion direction. This was well before the crows responded.
- Neural activity built up gradually as the decision formed, until it reached a decision threshold, and then the crow made its choice.
- The neurons reflected both the strength of the visual information and the direction chosen.
What Does It Mean?
Nieder said the findings show that neuron activity in the bird brain is consistent with established models of decision-making in humans and other primates.
Birds do not have a layered cerebral cortex, yet their differently organised brains seem to follow comparable basic principles, and they do so about twice as fast as primates. Nieder suggested the speed may come from birds’ evolutionary need for quick visual processing and fast motor responses during flight and foraging.
Quick Summary
- Who: University of Tübingen researchers, Philipp Schmidbauer and Andreas Nieder
- Subjects: Two carrion crows
- Task: Judge whether dots on a touchscreen move left or right
- Average decision time: 235 milliseconds
- Accuracy: Nearly 100% with clear signals
- Brain region: Nidopallium caudolaterale, similar to the human prefrontal cortex
- Published in: Science
What Should We Keep in Mind?
The experiment used two crows, so the results show what is possible for this species in this task. They do not mean crows are faster at every kind of thinking. The finding is mainly interesting because it shows that very different brain structures can solve the same decision problems, and in this case do it quickly.
