Nic Maddinson Makes 0 off 33 Balls on Test Return as Australia’s
Nic Maddinson’s comeback to Test cricket did not go to plan. The 34-year-old Australian opener faced 33 balls without scoring on the first day against South Africa in Durban. It was a painful return for a man who was fighting cancer only a year and a half ago, and it also put the spotlight on Australia’s selection choices and an ageing batting line-up.
A Comeback Story That Did Not Get Its Happy Ending
Maddinson’s recall was a surprise for several reasons. His last Test came almost 10 years ago, he has played three Tests in total, and he only returned to competitive cricket 12 months ago.
In April 2025 he was diagnosed with testicular cancer, which had spread to his lung and lymph nodes. He missed most of last year while going through surgery, chemotherapy and recovery.
The Longest Duck by an Australian Opener
Maddinson’s 33-ball duck is now:
- The longest duck by an Australian opener in Test history
- The third longest by any Test opener
Here is how it went:
- He missed 13 balls and edged one.
- He was finally out when he tried to cut a delivery from Marco Jansen and the ball crashed back onto his stumps.
- He could have been out much earlier. A leg-before appeal on the 15th ball he faced was turned down, and South Africa did not review it. Replays suggested the decision would have been overturned.
How Australia’s Innings Unfolded
| Batter | Age | How it ended |
|---|---|---|
| Nic Maddinson | 34 | Bowled by Marco Jansen, 0 off 33 |
| Travis Head | 32 | Caught down the leg side for 9 |
| Marnus Labuschagne | 32 | LBW to Wiaan Mulder for 37, last ball before lunch |
| Steve Smith | 37 | Edged Jansen to gully |
| Alex Carey | 35 | Fell to Anrich Nortje |
| Beau Webster | 32 | Fell to Anrich Nortje |
Australia slid to 124-6 before recovering to 187-6 when bad light ended the day early. Matt Renshaw was unbeaten on 46, batting with captain Pat Cummins. His knock eased some of the questions about why he was batting at number five, having been recalled as an opener for the Bangladesh series in August.
Labuschagne looked comfortable but is now 44 Test innings without a century.
The Selection Debate
Australia picked Maddinson over 23-year-old Cooper Connolly to replace injured all-rounder Cameron Green. With that choice, Australia named an XI made up entirely of players over 30 for the first time in their history.
Former opener Matthew Hayden criticised the decision before the match. He said it showed disrespect for first-class cricket, pointing out that Maddinson’s only professional appearances since March 2025 were two 50-over innings last month and four Big Bash games last winter.
Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg defended the selectors during the lunch break. He said they clearly rate Maddinson as a talent, that he understood why people were debating it, and that he would not discuss selection further.
Why Did Selectors Go This Way?
Selectors can point to a thin pool of batters. Apart from Jake Weatherald, who struggled in the Ashes and has since been dropped, no frontline batter averaged above 40 in last year’s Sheffield Shield.
An Ageing Squad and a Heavy Schedule
The bowling attack is also experienced. The back-up bowlers include Michael Neser (36) and Scott Boland (37), alongside Pat Cummins (33), Josh Hazlewood (35) and Mitchell Starc (36).
Australia face up to 21 Tests before the end of next summer’s Ashes. The run includes:
- This tour of South Africa, the world Test champions
- A four-Test home series against New Zealand
- A five-Test tour of India
- A possible World Test Championship final
- The Ashes against England
Such a packed calendar raises worries about succession planning and whether this older group can stay fit and in form.
Quick Summary
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Match | South Africa vs Australia Test, Durban |
| Maddinson’s score | 0 off 33 balls |
| Record | Longest duck by an Australian opener in Tests |
| Dismissed by | Marco Jansen |
| Australia at close | 187-6 (bad light) |
| Not out | Matt Renshaw 46, Pat Cummins |
| Selection controversy | Maddinson picked over Cooper Connolly (23) |
| Historic first | Australia’s first XI with every player over 30 |
| Possible Tests ahead | Up to 21 before next summer’s Ashes |
